In order to protect YamalThe Yamal Peninsula is located in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug of northwest Siberia, Russia. It extends roughly 700 km (435 mi). In the language of its indigenous inhabitants, the Nenets, "Yamal" means "End of the Land".
from preachers visiting NEIGHBORING Arctic tundra areas, the Government of the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous OkrugOkrug is name of an administrative district, or region, in Russia. sent budget funds for a closed conference on the subject «Destructive and pseudo-religious organizations, sects and cults: challenges and solutions» with invited participants from Canada, Germany and Italy.
The conference was held on September 27-29, 2017 in Salekhard in the building of the Government of Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Okrug (YANAO). The official organizers are the Government of the YANAO and the Salekhard Diocese of the Russian Orthodox Church. The order on holding the conference was signed by the Governor of YANAO Dmitry Kobylkin. The chairman of the organizing committee of the conference is the vice-governor Irina Sokolova, the co-chairman is the head of the Salekhard Diocese of the ROC Archbishop Nikolay (secular name Sergey Nikolaevich Chashin).
To get to the conference is possible only by invitation, ordinary visitors are not allowed — Roman Pikun, head of the National Policy and Public Relations Department of the Internal Policy Department of the YANAO, explained to us two days before the conference. But he added that the conference doors are open to all accredited journalists.
However, this was not entirely true. For example, journalist of the «Religious Studies Journal»Officially registered as a mass medium. Olesya Suchkova wrote that her accreditation was unexpectedly canceled because the organizers do not accept journalists from other regions.
«After some negotiations, I was still accredited, but after 15 minutes they called and reported interesting information. The spokeswoman said that she received an order to cancel all applications of «external» journalists, who are not part of the administration staff or any of their district press centers. It's good that I have not bought a flight tickets that can’t be refuneded.» — Olesya Suchkova writes.
There is an interesting situation. The conference, whose declared goal is the solution of a socially significant task, is actually closed to public access. In the same time it is financed by the state budget — ie. at the expense of taxpayers who can not even attend to it or learn how it passed from independent media. Not to mention to express their attitude to such a budget waste which is clearly questionable for the region’s value.
Archbishop Nikolay, ruling the Salekhard diocese of the Russian Orthodox Church, does not seem to consider the topic of sects actual for the region: «The North is now becoming overgrown with infrastructure, it is becoming more accessible. And we see that even in the tundra various preachers go around. But this is not so much actual for Yamal as for other places in our Arctic zone», he said a week before start of the conference.
The Mufti of the Spiritual Directorate of Muslims of the YANAO, Khaidar Hafizov, with whom the representative of our web-site communicated a few hours before the beginning of the event, is agree with archbishop Nikolay. The Mufti even expressed concern that non-traditional confessions want «[all] to become their adherents, sooner or later», but promised that «not to allow it with God's help" and made it clear that the region does not consider this problem topical.
According to Nadezhda Noskova, the head of the press service of the YANAO governor, «the region has remained stable and calm from the point of view of ethno-confessional and interethnic situation, but since this issue is becoming more acute all over the world, the okrug initiated such a conference, in order to protect themselves and other regions from future threats. This is a preventive measure.»
The doctor of philosophical sciences, professor of the department of state and confessional relations of the RANEPARussian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation William Shmidt, has a more pragmatic view on the goals of this conference:
«The situation as a whole is quite simple: there is a plan of measures to prevent extremism and terrorism, to prevent threats, and so on. What to do when, for example, you do not have them, and the funds for them are budgeted? (Budgets are, as you know, a delicate matter — they need to be handled, and under this section there should also be a report with a special responsibility.)»
We could not get an answer to the question why the Government of Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Okrug believes that this conference will strengthen interethnic and interconfessional unity — Roman Pikun, the head of the National Policy Department, first asked to postpone the phone conversation, and then did not pick up the phone.
But got known a very original reason for refusing access to the conference for external journalists. It turns out that press access has been restricted so as not to frighten people!
«The fact that external journalists were denied in access is not the fault of the press service. — Says the head of the press service Nadezhda Noskova. — And we apologize. We planned to show everything very broadly. The conference has several organizers: the regional department of internal policy, the Orthodox Church, the regional Muslim’s Spiritual Directorate and others. And at their general meeting it was decided not to frighten people... nevertheless the narrow specialists gathered and partly the event is half-closed.»
Who, in this case, should be frightened by this half-closed event? After all, in every speech there are such words as «totalitarian sect» or «destructive cult». Mufti Haydar Khafizov helped to answer this question.
«At this conference, if I'm not mistaken, the heads of municipalities will be present, and we are trying to convey to them the idea [of sects]. At local levels, there are no people who understand traditional religions. And today experts will speak and explain by what criteria it is possible [to determine who belongs to traditional religions and who is not]. Many have now opened... Whom only... Aum Shinrikyo, Here Krishnas, others, etc... Jehovah's Witnesses, Baptists... Sorry of course, I said too much. We need specialists at the local levels of administrations who oversee these issues. So I'm not saying of going back to repressions, but there must be specialists on the ground.» — Mufti Haydar Hafizov said.
Indeed, by the order of the Governor of YANAO, the heads of all the municipalities of the Okrug were advised not only to appear at the conference themselves, but also to ensure the attendance of the heads of settlements located in the territories of their districts.
5. To recommend the heads (heads of local administrations) of municipalities in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug to take part in the conference.
6. To recommend to the heads (heads of local administrations) of municipal districts in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug to assist in ensuring the participation in the conference of the heads of settlements that are part of the territory of the municipal district.
7. The control over the execution of this order shall be assigned to the vice-governor of the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Okrug.
— from the order of the governor Dmitry Kobylkin about the conference.
Within the framework of the conference and in the presence of the governor, Mufti of the Spiritual Directorate of Muslims of the YANAO Haydar Hafizov signed an agreement with the head of the Salekhard Diocese of the ROC, Archbishop Nikolay (Chashin), on cooperation in countering pseudo-religious organizations, sects, and on some other issues.
In this regard, we asked Haidar Hafizov about his attitude to one of the key speakers of the conference Alexander Dvorkin in view of the fact that he is known for lectures that «expose» Islam and causing a lot of outrage among Muslims since 2013. But it turned out that the mufti was not familiar with this aspect of the anticultist’s activity.
«I have not heard... I am familiar with his activities since last year, after Dvorkin came to Novy UrengoyMarch 31, 2015 in Novy Urengoy Dvorkin gave lectures against the sects.. But you know, to judge a man by his speeches... It is necessary to assess him on his acts. It's my opinion. And today, that's all, who is not too lazy... That's even what you are asking me... there are people who will find what to criticize...» — Mufti Haydar Hafizov
After the mufti was told a little about Dvorkin's anti-Islamic lectures in which a number of experts found extremism, insults, historical inaccuracies and distortions of facts, Haidar Hafizov said that his spiritual mentor is Supreme Mufti Talgat Tadzhuddin, «and from him I'm not heard anything bad about Dvorkin, and that's enough for me.» In turn, Talgat Tadzhuddin's assistant ignored our questions on this matter, which we addressed in writing at his request. Despite several reminders on the phone, no answers were received to them.
Considering the contingent of the conference speakers and anticipating the results, turned out that religious scholar, the deputy director of the Center for the Study and Development of Intercultural Relations Sergei Shcherbak was right:
«As far as I know, not only many scientists studying NRM, but also the media, supporting the ideas of religious freedom and ideological pluralism, were not admitted to the event. I can predict with absolute certainty that the reports will sound with a lot of joy and gratitude to the current authorities for a new sudden turn in relations between the state and confessions in Russia, which led to the elimination of the organizations of Scientologists and Jehovah's Witnesses from the official religious life.»
On the first day of the conference and in the first interview to the «Yamal-Region» television channel, Dvorkin spoke in support of the liquidation of Jehovah's Witnesses organizations based on the extremism law article.
«In fact, there are two types of extremism: one that is directed to the outside (the one that is equal to terrorism, roughly speaking) and the extremism that is directed inward, that is, to members of the organization itself.» — right in the course of an interview in the studio of the channel, Dvorkin introduces new definition of extremismFederal Law No. 114-FZ "On Countering Extremist Activity" does not provide for such a notion of extremism, as Dvorkin explains., explaining the reason for the elimination of the JW.
Speaking of such events in general, Sergei Shcherbak does not see any benefit in them — neither economic nor practical:
«As for the public benefit of such events, to the best of my knowledge, at the expense of the regional budgets, as well as special grants allocated from the federal budget to fight extremism, it seems to me doubtful.
The search for extremist content in religious texts often recalls the efforts of the ancient Sophists who earned their living by verbal balancing act. It is not difficult to find extremist statements and ideas in ancient and modern sacred books of known religions, and not only in the Tanakh, the New Testament or the Koran, but, for example, in Orthodox patristic literature, books on Islam, as well as in some contemporary utterances of religious hierarchs. But it would be strange if scholars of religious studies were engaged in something similar, gathering conferences about the extremist danger of Christianity or Islam under the pretext of extremism.
Another point is that representatives of anti-cult centers are questioning the right of a citizen of our country to decide what to believe and what beliefs to share. All this is alarming. The assertion that unusual views of the world are vicious leads not only to the spread of intolerance and enmity towards dissidents in society, but also, in the final analysis, harms the religions that exist for centuries in Russia.
This thought was expressed more than two thousand years ago by the wise Ashoka: «... Those who praises his religion, because of excessive devotion, and defames others, having the thought: «I glorify my religion this way», only harms their own religion. Therefore it is useful to discuss. One should listen and respect the doctrines preached by others.» (The EdictEdict — a decree issued by a sovereign or other authority. It was literally put in stone. of the Rock 12, 265 BC). I'm not sure that at the conference in Salekhard they will listen to the opinion of the respected ancient Indian emperor.»
They did not listen.
«Everyone living on our northern land makes unique contribution to its development. That is why we regard the ethnic and confessional diversity in Yamal as an advantage», with these words Dmitry Kobylkin concluded his greeting to the participants of the anti-religious conference.
This is the main paradox of this event. Indeed, how can the conference, which is anti-confessional in nature, contribute to the diversity of confessions?
«The Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug combines favorable conditions for the life of representatives of different peoples and confessions of the Russian Federation, including for the indigenous small-numbered peoples of the North.» — states the information provided by the press service of the governor together with the photos of the conference.
The problem is that the legal term «sect» does not exist, and the interpretation of this term by anticultists is so blurry that in the final analysis, only they themselves decide what will be considered a sect at a particular moment in time and what will not.
So a sect can be called both independent religious movements and monasteries, from which, in view of some scandal, the Russian Orthodox Church is trying to dissociate itself; with the easy hand of Dvorkin, commercial organizations such as Herbalife and the «Forex» Stock Exchange are became sects; same for individual Hindu schools, yoga courses and even breastfeeding and home delivery courses; and in 2013 attempts began to undermine the reputation of the world religion Islam. As experience shows, the «Anticultist #1» does not care what to attack, be it the world religion or the beliefs of the indigenous small-numbered peoples of the North.
Among the speakers we did not find a single religious scholar. But each of them is an adherent of one ideology that denies the human right to choose what to believe in and how to believe, guaranteed by the Constitution. And this right is denied under the guise of helping the person himself. Each report is a set of phrases unidentified by science. «Totalitarian sect», «destructive cult», «psycho-cult» — cliches, the meaning of which is changed by an author from situation to situation.
Speakers of the conference:
The conference, announced as the scientific and practical, us very far from science. Rather, it is a meeting of colleagues of the same business, who are going to talk and have a good time at the public expense. Evidence of this are both the composition of participants and similar reports, the content of which is repeated from year to year, from conference to conference.
All speakers are close people. You can say, members of one club of interests. Gandow, Armstrong and Dvorkin have been friends for over 20 years. Corvaglia and Dvorkin are members of the FECRIS board. Silantiev, Voat and Dvorkin are anticultists and members of the RATSIRSRussian Association of Centers for Studying Cults and Sects, founded by Dvorkin in 2006. headed by Dvorkin. Representatives of the Orthodox Church are also guides of the anti-sectarian politic.
«The study of religions and sects in modern Russia» — this is the title of the report of Dvorkin himself. At the same time, several hours earlier the same day in an interview with the «Yamal-Region» TV Channel, he said that he still has no statistics of religions and sects. This is for 25 years of work! What kind of study of religions and sects can we talk about?
Journalist: Alexander Leonidovich, a couple of years ago you said that we should carefully investigate the problem of sectarianism, collect information, conduct researches in order to keep relevant statistics, which we do not have yet. And how it is today? Did you manage to make any statistics?
Dvorkin: You know, there are still no statistics.
— TV Channel «Yamal-region», September 27, 2017
What are all the reasons for the conduct and what are the expected consequences of such conferences? To find answer to this question helped religious scholar William Schmidt. In his opinion, the purpose is political-ideological noise, as part of the state strategy. However, this noise can lead to very unpleasant consequences, including for traditional religions.
«In recent years, we have a stable tendency to politicize and criminalize the religious sphere, mainly due to so-called non-traditional movements and cults (groups). How much they pose a real threat to public order or anything else, considering their %, proportion in the population composition, or the social structure, — is an insignificant issue, since it do not even fall into the category of statistical error.
But there is a lot of political-ideological noise around them. That's it, this «noise» is the main and politically valuable. You will think that this is contrary to constitutional norms and principles, but at stake are real riots on social-political-economic grounds...
It's also sad that the big players on the religious field do not see or are not allowed to see the context and costs that are formed as a result of such activities, and in fact it is the strategy of the state's domestic policy, which only now can be perceived as costs, but at the long term, in the part of generalization of law enforcement practice, will become the common moment of regulation...
What the regional authorities have to do, if they are in rigid political-ideological and socio-economic linkages / dependencies — they must «link up».
That is why this «funny team» is touring the country, honestly earning a living.»
Update: In accordance with the official response of the acting Director of the Department of Internal Policy of the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Okrug E.A.Baidanova «The event was aimed, among other things, to resolve issues related to the maintenance of interethnic and interreligious peace and harmony, and the prevention of conflict situations.» Baidanova refers to the Federal Law No.184 of October 6, 1999 «On general principles of the organization of legislative (representative) and executive bodies of state power of the subjects of the Russian Federation», in accordance with which the executive body is obliged to guarantee rights and freedoms of a citizen regardless of race and religion and to prevent discrimination based on national or religious affiliation.
«The costs associated with participation of the Government of the Autonomous Okrug in the conduct of the conference (the working hours of state civil servants, the work of the press service, information support, maintenance, rent of premises) are not subject to any valuation in a specific monetary form, since such participation is part of activity of an officials...» — writes E.A.Baidanova.
According to the answer, the conference financing (in addition to the above costs, which are not subject to evaluation in a specific monetary form) was carried out from extrabudgetary sources. Such sources were named the Salekhard diocese of the Russian Orthodox Church, the Regional Spiritual Directorate of Muslims and the non-profit organization «The Foundation for Cooperation of Yamal»According to the Unified State Register of Legal Entities, the sole founder of »The Foundation for Cooperation of Yamal» is the Department of International and Foreign Economic Relations of YaNAO. The chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Foundation is the Deputy Governor Alexander Mazharov (who is also the Director of the Department for International and Foreign Economic Relations). The council also includes the vice-governor of YaNAO Irina Sokolova (she is also the chairman of the organizing committee of the conference), the business ombudsman Dmitry Bavdurny and the deputy director of the finance department Svetlana Laptander.
According to URA.ru, in 2016 the Foundation received a subsidy of 350 million rubles from the regional budget. According to the state procurement portal, the Foundation is the largest provider of services for the Department for International and Foreign Economic Relations.
According to reports, in 2015 most of the money from this foundation, almost 482 million rubles, was sent to support religious organizations, including more than 400 million rubles for the construction of a new Orthodox church in Salekhard., while these organizations entered into a legal relationship between themselves, without transferring funds to the budget of the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous District.
According to the answer, the Department of International and External Economic Relations of the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous District, which was included in the organizational committee of the conference by order of the Government dated June 19, 2017 No.443-RP, sent invitations to foreign participants of the conference (Gerald Armstrong, Thomas Gandow, Luigi Corvaglia).
Participation in the conference of the heads of local administrations, according to the answer, did not entail additional expenditure on travel expenses, since their arrival and participation in the conference were planned in such a way that they coincided with another eventAccording to an official press release, the Council of Heads of Municipalities did indeed took place on September 29, but the conference was held on 27, 28 and 29 September., namely, — Council of Heads of Municipalities. Accommodation of heads of administrations during the conference was also provided at the expense of travel expenses.
«The Salekhard Diocese of the Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate), the Regional Spiritual Board of Moslems of the Autonomous Okrug and the non-profit organization «The Foundation for Cooperation of Yamal» dealt with the residence of other participants, including Orthodox and Muslim clerics. The program of the event provided for the time for participants to eat at their places of residence, which they carried out independently for individual needs.» — finished her answer E.A. Baydanova.
September 30, 2017
13 февраля Если это окажется правдой...